usher-manage-stack/.planning/phases/03-note-history-display/03-VERIFICATION.md

phase, verified, status, score, re_verification

phase	verified	status	score	re_verification
03-note-history-display	2026-02-13T05:03:47Z	passed	6/6 must-haves verified	false

Phase 3: Note History & Display Verification Report

Phase Goal: Complete the note feature with full history viewing and search

Verified: 2026-02-13T05:03:47Z

Status: passed

Re-verification: No — initial verification

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	Admin clicks note count badge and an inline panel expands below the row showing all notes for that member	✓ VERIFIED	Button with @click="toggleHistory()" at line 305, expansion panel <tr> with x-show="historyOpen" and x-collapse at line 367, proper aria-expanded and aria-controls attributes
2	Notes display newest first with author name and formatted datetime (YYYY年MM月DD日 HH:mm)	✓ VERIFIED	Controller uses ->latest('created_at') at line 18, Blade displays note.author.name and formatDateTime(note.created_at) at lines 399-401, formatDateTime method properly formats to Traditional Chinese at lines 257-264
3	Panel shows '尚無備註' when member has no notes	✓ VERIFIED	Empty state template at line 409-410 with condition notesLoaded && notes.length === 0
4	Admin can type in a search field to filter notes by text content or author name	✓ VERIFIED	Search input at line 385-389 with x-model="searchQuery", filteredNotes computed property at lines 249-256 filters by both content and author name (case-insensitive)
5	Panel collapses cleanly when badge is clicked again, search query resets, other rows are unaffected	✓ VERIFIED	toggleHistory() at lines 228-235 toggles historyOpen state and resets searchQuery when closing, each member row has isolated Alpine.js scope via template wrapper (line 196)
6	After adding a note via inline form, the history panel (if previously opened) shows the new note immediately without re-fetching	✓ VERIFIED	submitNote() at line 218 has this.notes.unshift(response.data.note) cache sync, store endpoint returns note with author (MemberNoteController line 44)

Score: 6/6 truths verified

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Expected	Status	Details
resources/js/app.js	Alpine.js collapse plugin registration	✓ VERIFIED	Lines 4-6: imports collapse plugin and registers with Alpine.plugin(collapse) before Alpine.start()
resources/views/admin/members/index.blade.php	Expandable note history panel with search	✓ VERIFIED	Complete implementation: template wrapper (line 196), toggleHistory method (228-235), expansion panel (367-419), search input (385-389), filteredNotes computed property (249-256), empty states (409-415)
app/Http/Controllers/Admin/MemberNoteController.php	Notes endpoint with newest-first ordering and eager-loaded author	✓ VERIFIED	Line 18: ->with('author:id,name')->latest('created_at') - explicit ordering with optimized eager loading
tests/Feature/Admin/MemberNoteTest.php	Tests verifying ordering, empty state, and search-related data	✓ VERIFIED	11 tests total (7 existing + 4 new), all pass. New tests cover: author+datetime in response, empty state response, Blade directives, cache sync data

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
Blade view	GET /admin/members/{member}/notes	axios.get in toggleHistory()	✓ WIRED	Line 240: axios.get('{{ route("admin.members.notes.index", $member) }}') called in loadNotes(), invoked by toggleHistory()
Blade view	resources/js/app.js	Alpine.plugin(collapse) enables x-collapse	✓ WIRED	app.js line 6 registers collapse plugin, Blade line 367 uses x-collapse directive on expansion row
submitNote	notes.unshift	Cache sync after note creation	✓ WIRED	Line 218: this.notes.unshift(response.data.note) in submitNote() success handler, conditioned on notesLoaded (line 217)

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Status	Supporting Truths
DISP-02: View all notes for a member	✓ SATISFIED	Truths 1, 2 - expandable panel shows all notes with proper formatting
DISP-03: Notes ordered newest first	✓ SATISFIED	Truth 2 - controller explicit ordering + formatDateTime display
DISP-04: Search/filter notes	✓ SATISFIED	Truth 4 - client-side search by content and author

Anti-Patterns Found

File	Line	Pattern	Severity	Impact
resources/views/admin/members/index.blade.php	244	console.error in catch block	ℹ️ Info	Acceptable - proper error handling for failed note loading

No blocker or warning anti-patterns found.

Human Verification Required

1. Visual Collapse Animation Smoothness

Test:

1. Login as admin
2. Navigate to member list
3. Click note count badge on a member with notes
4. Observe expansion animation
5. Click badge again to collapse

Expected:

• Panel expands smoothly with slide-down animation
• Panel collapses smoothly with slide-up animation
• No visual jank or layout shift
• Other member rows remain stationary during expansion/collapse

Why human: Visual animation quality and smoothness cannot be verified programmatically

2. Search Filtering Responsiveness

Test:

1. Open note history panel for member with multiple notes
2. Type in search field: "test"
3. Verify only matching notes shown
4. Clear search field
5. Verify all notes reappear

Expected:

• Search filters in real-time as user types
• Filter is case-insensitive
• Both content and author name are searchable
• No flickering or lag during filtering

Why human: Real-time interactivity feel requires human observation

3. Empty State Display

Test:

1. Find member with zero notes (or create one)
2. Click note count badge
3. Verify "尚無備註" message displays

Expected:

• Empty state message appears centered
• Message is styled consistently with rest of panel
• No loading spinner stuck visible

Why human: Visual appearance and styling verification

4. Multi-Member Panel Isolation

Test:

1. Open note history panel for Member A
2. Without closing, click note count badge for Member B
3. Verify Member A's panel closes and Member B's panel opens

Expected:

• Only one panel open at a time
• No state leakage between member rows
• Each member's search query is independent

Why human: Complex state interaction across multiple Alpine.js scopes

5. Cache Sync After Inline Add

Test:

1. Open note history panel for a member
2. Keep panel open
3. Use inline quick-add form to add new note
4. Verify new note appears at top of history panel immediately

Expected:

• New note appears instantly without panel refresh
• No duplicate note entries
• Note shows correct author name and timestamp

Why human: Complex interaction between two Alpine.js features (inline form + history panel)

---

Verified: 2026-02-13T05:03:47Z
Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)