usher-exploring/.planning/phases/05-output-cli/05-VERIFICATION.md

phase, verified, status, score, re_verification

phase	verified	status	score	re_verification
05-output-cli	2026-02-12T12:00:00Z	passed	6/6 success criteria verified	false

Phase 5: Output & CLI Verification Report

Phase Goal: User-facing interface and structured tiered output Verified: 2026-02-12T12:00:00Z Status: passed Re-verification: No - initial verification

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	Pipeline produces tiered candidate list (high/medium/low confidence) based on composite score and evidence breadth	✓ VERIFIED	assign_tiers() in tiers.py implements configurable thresholds (HIGH: score>=0.7 & evidence>=3, MEDIUM: score>=0.4 & evidence>=2, LOW: score>=0.2). Uses vectorized polars when/then/otherwise chains. EXCLUDED genes filtered out.
2	Each candidate includes multi-dimensional evidence summary showing which layers support it and which have gaps	✓ VERIFIED	add_evidence_summary() in evidence_summary.py adds supporting_layers (comma-separated list of non-NULL scores) and evidence_gaps (comma-separated list of NULL scores). Uses polars concat_list + list.drop_nulls + list.join.
3	Output is available in TSV and Parquet formats compatible with downstream tools	✓ VERIFIED	write_candidate_output() in writers.py writes both TSV (tab separator) and Parquet (snappy compression) with identical data. Includes YAML provenance sidecar with statistics, column metadata. Deterministic sorting (composite_score DESC, gene_id ASC).
4	Pipeline generates visualizations: score distribution, evidence layer contribution, tier breakdown	✓ VERIFIED	visualizations.py implements plot_score_distribution() (histogram colored by tier), plot_layer_contributions() (bar chart of layer coverage), plot_tier_breakdown() (pie chart). All saved at 300 DPI. matplotlib Agg backend (headless-safe). Proper plt.close() to prevent memory leaks. generate_all_plots() orchestrates with error handling.
5	Unified CLI provides subcommands for running layers, integration, and reporting with progress logging	✓ VERIFIED	report_cmd.py implements full CLI command registered in main.py. Follows established pattern: config load, store init, checkpoint check, pipeline steps with click.style output, summary, cleanup. Supports --output-dir, --force, --skip-viz, --skip-report, configurable tier thresholds. Integrates all output modules: assign_tiers, add_evidence_summary, write_candidate_output, generate_all_plots, generate_reproducibility_report.
6	Reproducibility report documents all parameters, data versions, gene counts at filtering steps, and validation metrics	✓ VERIFIED	reproducibility.py implements ReproducibilityReport dataclass with to_json() and to_markdown() methods. generate_reproducibility_report() extracts parameters from config.scoring.model_dump(), data_versions from config.versions.model_dump(), software versions (Python, polars, duckdb), filtering steps from provenance.get_steps(), tier statistics, and optional validation metrics.

Score: 6/6 truths verified

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Expected	Status	Details
src/usher_pipeline/output/tiers.py	Confidence tiering logic	✓ VERIFIED	84 lines. Exports assign_tiers, TIER_THRESHOLDS. Uses polars when/then/otherwise chains. Filters EXCLUDED genes. Deterministic sorting.
src/usher_pipeline/output/evidence_summary.py	Per-gene evidence summary columns	✓ VERIFIED	83 lines. Exports add_evidence_summary, EVIDENCE_LAYERS. Uses concat_list + list.drop_nulls + list.join for comma-separated strings.
src/usher_pipeline/output/writers.py	Dual-format TSV+Parquet writer	✓ VERIFIED	105 lines. Exports write_candidate_output. Writes TSV (tab separator), Parquet (snappy), and YAML provenance sidecar. Computes tier statistics.
src/usher_pipeline/output/visualizations.py	matplotlib/seaborn visualization functions	✓ VERIFIED	245 lines. Exports plot_score_distribution, plot_layer_contributions, plot_tier_breakdown, generate_all_plots. Uses Agg backend. 300 DPI output. Proper plt.close().
src/usher_pipeline/output/reproducibility.py	Reproducibility report generation	✓ VERIFIED	321 lines. Exports ReproducibilityReport, FilteringStep, generate_reproducibility_report. JSON and Markdown output. Extracts config, provenance, tier stats, validation metrics.
src/usher_pipeline/output/init.py	Package exports	✓ VERIFIED	30 lines. Exports all functions from tiers, evidence_summary, writers, visualizations, reproducibility.
src/usher_pipeline/cli/report_cmd.py	CLI report command	✓ VERIFIED	400+ lines. Orchestrates full output pipeline. Supports --output-dir, --force, --skip-viz, --skip-report, tier threshold flags. Error handling, progress logging, checkpoint pattern.
tests/test_output.py	Unit tests for output module	✓ VERIFIED	602 lines. 9 tests covering tiering, evidence summary, writers, provenance.
tests/test_visualizations.py	Tests for visualization generation	✓ VERIFIED	112 lines. 6 tests for plot creation, empty DataFrame handling.
tests/test_reproducibility.py	Tests for report content	✓ VERIFIED	245 lines. 7 tests for report fields, JSON/Markdown output, validation metrics.
tests/test_report_cmd.py	CliRunner integration tests	✓ VERIFIED	308 lines. 9 tests for CLI command with synthetic fixtures.

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
tiers.py	scored_genes DataFrame	polars expressions with composite_score and evidence_count	✓ WIRED	Lines 62-68 use pl.col("composite_score") and pl.col("evidence_count") in when/then chains. Line 81 sorts by composite_score DESC.
writers.py	TSV and Parquet files	polars write_csv and write_parquet	✓ WIRED	Line 66: df.write_csv(tsv_path, separator="\t"). Line 69: df.write_parquet(parquet_path, compression="snappy").
visualizations.py	matplotlib/seaborn	to_pandas() conversion	✓ WIRED	Line 35: pdf = df.to_pandas(). Lines 38, 44, 116: sns.set_theme(), sns.histplot(), sns.barplot().
reproducibility.py	config and provenance	model_dump() extraction	✓ WIRED	Line 239: parameters = config.scoring.model_dump(). Line 242: data_versions = config.versions.model_dump(). Line 253: provenance.get_steps().
report_cmd.py	output modules	imports and function calls	✓ WIRED	Lines 19-25: imports assign_tiers, add_evidence_summary, write_candidate_output, generate_all_plots, generate_reproducibility_report. Lines 215, 246, 262, 300, 337: calls to all imported functions.
main.py	report_cmd.py	cli.add_command(report)	✓ WIRED	Line 16: from usher_pipeline.cli.report_cmd import report. Line 105: cli.add_command(report).

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Status	Supporting Evidence
OUTP-01: Tiered candidate list (high/medium/low confidence) based on composite score and evidence breadth	✓ SATISFIED	tiers.py assign_tiers() with configurable thresholds. CLI report command applies tiering.
OUTP-02: Multi-dimensional evidence summary showing which layers support and which have gaps	✓ SATISFIED	evidence_summary.py add_evidence_summary() adds supporting_layers and evidence_gaps columns.
OUTP-03: Structured machine-readable format (TSV and Parquet) compatible with downstream tools	✓ SATISFIED	writers.py write_candidate_output() produces TSV and Parquet with identical data. YAML provenance sidecar includes column metadata.
OUTP-04: Basic visualizations (score distribution, evidence layer contribution, tier breakdown)	✓ SATISFIED	visualizations.py implements all 3 plot types at 300 DPI. generate_all_plots() orchestrates.
OUTP-05: Reproducibility report documenting parameters, data versions, gene counts, validation metrics	✓ SATISFIED	reproducibility.py generate_reproducibility_report() creates JSON and Markdown with all required metadata.

Anti-Patterns Found

None. No TODO/FIXME/PLACEHOLDER comments, no stub implementations, no empty returns found in output modules or report_cmd.py.

Commits Verified

All commits from SUMMARYs exist in git history:

• d2ef3a2: feat(05-01): implement tiering logic and evidence summary module
• 4e46b48: feat(05-01): add dual-format writer with provenance and tests
• 150417f: feat(05-02): implement visualization module with matplotlib/seaborn plots
• 5af63ea: feat(05-02): implement reproducibility report module with JSON and Markdown output
• 2ab25ef: feat(05-03): implement CLI report command
• c10d595: test(05-03): add CliRunner integration tests for report command

Test Coverage

Test File	Tests	Status
test_output.py	9	✓ VERIFIED (test count matches SUMMARY claim)
test_visualizations.py	6	✓ VERIFIED (test count matches SUMMARY claim)
test_reproducibility.py	7	✓ VERIFIED (test count matches SUMMARY claim)
test_report_cmd.py	9	✓ VERIFIED (test count matches SUMMARY claim)

Note: Tests cannot run due to dependency resolution issue (cellxgene-census version conflict), but test files exist with substantive implementations matching SUMMARY descriptions.

Overall Status

Status: passed

All 6 success criteria are verified. All artifacts exist and are substantive. All key links are wired correctly. No anti-patterns detected. All commits exist. Test files exist with correct test counts.

The phase goal "User-facing interface and structured tiered output" is fully achieved:

1. Tiered candidate classification (HIGH/MEDIUM/LOW) based on composite score and evidence breadth
2. Multi-dimensional evidence summary (supporting_layers and evidence_gaps)
3. Dual-format output (TSV and Parquet) with YAML provenance sidecars
4. Visualizations (score distribution, layer contributions, tier breakdown) at 300 DPI
5. Unified CLI report command integrating all output modules
6. Reproducibility reports (JSON and Markdown) with parameters, versions, filtering steps, validation metrics

---

Verified: 2026-02-12T12:00:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)