Codex round-3 verification (commit 9e68f2e) flagged remaining items:
BLOCKER:
- Appendix A Table A.I was inside an HTML comment but visible prose at L1268
and L1275 referenced it as if it rendered. Un-commented Table A.I (same fix
pattern as Tables I-IV in round-3).
MAJOR:
- Table XXVII (diagnostic summary) appeared in §III-M at L593 before Tables
III-XXVI in §IV, breaking sequential IEEE-style numbering. Moved the table
to Appendix A as Table A.II (new §A.2 "Diagnostic Summary"). §III-M now
references "Appendix A Table A.II" instead of hosting the table inline;
§VI Conclusion contribution (8) updated similarly. Appendix A heading
generalised to "Supplementary Diagnostic Detail" with §A.1 (BD/McCrary)
and §A.2 (Diagnostic Summary).
- §III-M L614 rate-definition conflation: the sentence "per-signature and
per-document rates ($0.11$ and $0.34$ respectively under the deployed
any-pair HC + MC alarm)" mixed unit labels. Rewrote to label each rate by
its actual unit and source table: per-signature any-pair HC ICCR ($0.11$;
Table XXII) and per-document HC+MC alarm-rate ICCR ($0.34$; Table XXIII).
MINORS:
- L400 §III-L stale ref retargeted: "operational signature-level classifier
of §III-L" -> "of §III-H.1 calibrated in §III-L".
- L663 §III-L stale ref retargeted: "KDE crossover used in per-document
classification (Section III-L)" -> "(Section III-H.1)".
- L1146 Conclusion "corpus-universal" overstated generality -> "across the
tested eligible scopes" (non-Big-4 evidence is cosine-axis only, not full
calibration scope).
- L1024 Results §IV-M.4 footnote: np.argmax / np.unique implementation
detail moved to "alphabetically-ordered tie-break ... full implementation
detail in the supplementary materials" (less script-internal prose).
Artefacts:
- Combined manuscript regenerated: paper_a_v4_combined.md, 1316 lines.
- Final main-text table sequence: I, II, III, ..., XXVI (26 tables, all
sequential in rendered order). Appendix tables: A.I, A.II.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
gbanyan
bbb662acd1