paper/gemini_review_v3_19_0.md: 45 lines (cleaned from raw output that
included CLI 429 retry noise). Gemini round-20 confirmed all four
round-19 Major Revision findings are RESOLVED in v3.19.0:
- 656-document exclusion explanation: VERIFIED-AGAINST-ARTIFACT
(matches 09_pdf_signature_verdict.py L44 filtering logic).
- Table XIII provenance: VERIFIED-AGAINST-ARTIFACT (deterministically
reproduced by new 29_firm_a_yearly_distribution.py).
- 2-CPA disambiguation rewrite: VERIFIED-AGAINST-ARTIFACT (matches the
NULL filter in 24_validation_recalibration.py).
- Inter-CPA negative anchor: VERIFIED-AGAINST-ARTIFACT (50k i.i.d.
pairs from full 168k matched corpus, no LIMIT-3000 sub-sample).
Verdict: Accept. "None required. The manuscript is methodologically
sound, narratively disciplined, and ready for publication as-is."
This is the first Accept verdict in the 20-round cycle that comes
directly after a Major Revision (round 19) was fully processed. Prior
Accepts (round 7 Gemini, round 15 Gemini) were both later overturned by
codex on independent re-audit. The current state has the strongest
evidence base in the cycle: 4 distinct artifact verifications behind
each previously fabricated claim.
Remaining UNVERIFIABLE-but-acceptable items (758 CPAs / 15 doc types,
Qwen2.5-VL config, YOLO metrics, 43.1 docs/sec throughput) are now
classified by Gemini as "non-critical context" — supplement-material
candidates but not main-paper review blockers.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
gbanyan
4c3bcfa288