pdf_signature_extraction

gbanyan/pdf_signature_extraction

Fork 0

Commit Graph

Author	SHA1	Message	Date
gbanyan	9604b273c0	Apply codex round-7 Phase 5 copy-edit fixes + refresh STATE.md Mechanical copy-edit closing the OPEN/PARTIAL items from paper/codex_review_gpt55_v4_round7.md; substantive empirical content unchanged. Manuscript-splice items (strip internal draft notes, update stale abstract-count note) deferred to final splice. - Phase 4 prose §V-G + §III-K methodology: "candidate classifiers" -> "candidate checks" (closes round-7 m13 + Spot-check 3 wording leak) - Phase 4 prose §II: remove placeholder caveat sentence at the LOOO paragraph (closes round-7 M6 + A4) - References v3: add [42] Stone 1974, [43] Geisser 1975, [44] Vehtari et al. 2017 (44 entries; was 41) — backs the §II LOOO addition - Round-7 review: add row-count clarification note (11 Major / 15 Minor labelled rows vs. the prompt's 9/12 tally) - STATE.md: refresh from stale Phase-2 snapshot to current Phase 5 status — Phases 1-4 complete; codex rounds 1-7 closed at Minor Revision; pending Gemini + Opus rounds + round-2/3 convergence Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>	2026-05-14 14:21:59 +08:00
gbanyan	6db5d635f5	Apply codex round-27 narrow fixes; Phase 4 prose v2.1 Codex round 27 returned Minor Revision: 10/11 Major + 14/15 Minor CLOSED. Two narrow residuals applied: 1. §V-F line 99 'all three candidate classifiers' replaced with 'all three candidate checks' with explicit enumeration (the inherited box rule, the K=3 hard label, and the prevalence-calibrated reverse-anchor cut). Keeps the K=3 hard label explicitly descriptive rather than operational. 2. Close-out checklist's stale '~235 words' abstract claim updated to the verified 243-244 word count. Deferred to manuscript-assembly time (not blockers for Phase 5 cross-AI peer review): - §II [42]-[44] citation finalisation (placeholders are transparent in the current draft state). - Internal draft notes and close-out checklists (these explicitly help reviewers track the convergence cycle). - Manuscript-level lint pass (last step before submission packaging). Closure summary across 7 codex rounds (21-27): - Empirical: ALL Major + Minor findings CLOSED on the §III/§IV/Phase 4 substantive content. - Packaging: 2 OPEN items (§II citations, internal notes) intentionally deferred to manuscript-assembly time. Phase 5 readiness: substantively YES. The §III v6 + §IV v3.2 + Phase 4 v2.1 is converged for cross-AI peer review. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> EOF	2026-05-13 00:15:35 +08:00

Author

SHA1

Message

Date

gbanyan

9604b273c0

Apply codex round-7 Phase 5 copy-edit fixes + refresh STATE.md

Mechanical copy-edit closing the OPEN/PARTIAL items from
paper/codex_review_gpt55_v4_round7.md; substantive empirical
content unchanged. Manuscript-splice items (strip internal draft
notes, update stale abstract-count note) deferred to final splice.

- Phase 4 prose §V-G + §III-K methodology: "candidate classifiers"
  -> "candidate checks" (closes round-7 m13 + Spot-check 3 wording leak)
- Phase 4 prose §II: remove placeholder caveat sentence at the LOOO
  paragraph (closes round-7 M6 + A4)
- References v3: add [42] Stone 1974, [43] Geisser 1975, [44] Vehtari
  et al. 2017 (44 entries; was 41) — backs the §II LOOO addition
- Round-7 review: add row-count clarification note (11 Major / 15
  Minor labelled rows vs. the prompt's 9/12 tally)
- STATE.md: refresh from stale Phase-2 snapshot to current Phase 5
  status — Phases 1-4 complete; codex rounds 1-7 closed at Minor
  Revision; pending Gemini + Opus rounds + round-2/3 convergence

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-05-14 14:21:59 +08:00

gbanyan

6db5d635f5

Apply codex round-27 narrow fixes; Phase 4 prose v2.1

Codex round 27 returned Minor Revision: 10/11 Major + 14/15 Minor
CLOSED. Two narrow residuals applied:

  1. §V-F line 99 'all three candidate classifiers' replaced with
     'all three candidate checks' with explicit enumeration
     (the inherited box rule, the K=3 hard label, and the
     prevalence-calibrated reverse-anchor cut). Keeps the K=3
     hard label explicitly descriptive rather than operational.

  2. Close-out checklist's stale '~235 words' abstract claim
     updated to the verified 243-244 word count.

Deferred to manuscript-assembly time (not blockers for Phase 5
cross-AI peer review):
  - §II [42]-[44] citation finalisation (placeholders are
    transparent in the current draft state).
  - Internal draft notes and close-out checklists (these
    explicitly help reviewers track the convergence cycle).
  - Manuscript-level lint pass (last step before submission
    packaging).

Closure summary across 7 codex rounds (21-27):
  - Empirical: ALL Major + Minor findings CLOSED on the
    §III/§IV/Phase 4 substantive content.
  - Packaging: 2 OPEN items (§II citations, internal notes)
    intentionally deferred to manuscript-assembly time.

Phase 5 readiness: substantively YES. The §III v6 + §IV v3.2 +
Phase 4 v2.1 is converged for cross-AI peer review.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
EOF

2026-05-13 00:15:35 +08:00

2 Commits