From dd7b0644d58ba922242fd395b4f85f45bba6c86e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: gbanyan Date: Tue, 23 Jun 2026 15:56:50 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Paper A v13: add one-page Chinese change summary for co-author (Jimmy) Standalone summary (md + docx) of the rev8->rev9.1 revisions for co-author review: claim-honesty changes (retract 139x, HC != reuse, specificity proxy, Firm A as known-positive, interviews as contextual), empirical additions (Table VI same-pair, F5 four-check suite, Table V pipeline audit, byte-id era split), three judgment calls needing sign-off (framing rebalance not relabel, no within-CPA hand-sign benchmark, pipeline finding is double-edged), and remaining author-only items. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Qn59FdF9JMyfFg3sjcUNNG --- paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.docx | Bin 0 -> 14423 bytes paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.md | 38 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 38 insertions(+) create mode 100644 paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.docx create mode 100644 paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.md diff --git a/paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.docx b/paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.docx new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d1282f880a23f2317b1195b40c4b8dbf32c81e99 GIT binary patch literal 14423 zcmZ{L19)Z2)@^Jj9ox2T+crD4ZKq?~wv&$8v7L^Mj{S1Zz5jns_j_;eZ>^1QkGX2k znsZf+QM2TwfI(0IfFK|M%6XQwAVkLV-C-@ z5vs+vQlFGRI!_BBa+0#Ce$=LTX-K)(UqGI&2WP-R&I_+tV5XY10Y#THbI0#6QUSXL zW-}Bny6+EoR}-X5$;0+P3F17P2DRPJ+m;Ws*jierfj)IUO4sMIL6XKsB*0VD=$d| z$}Wci%W*gjZ$?nveu!_|4Obk`k&N@3Pi{H{a;SE3oHo*JW0G|p+@H1tMRJ)_i5@g> zg$XJ->k&i%Kczy48Goz3=FxOI6`cQA8YPqetl008>)RnNi1%8`!t zuX9zrj4Ut%jA#v#`_?rIlwhd^TdATeL=v!ixEX2wlfsT*8xJ5sZYhk86UO1qO~U?@ z!)41!nxj2~c`7RnIUK1bng?ub#=;(0a^w@Rt;E-S7}_r?T7on5VTD=)hG6%~>8b4V zIkcv7iaBk=!Uy3VLy^s0L$3*dq0&vwn7>wK1*~)L8g8)nM#A*MC5zV^ z%-zCQ^53Z0zCc68p8l9D>-YSrzapzx{icDPVp~$~s5cHuQKV2bK9}^q$?JhyPaH&Q zii_qU7lo;l#mlHC>t>f3$@aTH+hvnzU2p^o_o7wPj*LlY`f7=;U40=!LLL zS)S69ww+e%MbD{!_xGt2NGPlCr( z?MVUKfr)+(;M~U6ZDd-w{d{k2OM|Yv@NKrRL*{Bm_Lq4!BD#;CMe9Qtg1|=R>m0WaYjCpx*8=dtT!R3+dU%J*Xg8x|D~hw@6fF(ZOZ zHcu5A~J|dmaKg zA3=7bj#KlmAfE5HQY2^Tmzrf_@SHNp63jf|#r^mRcyCj7E|`}X@zTg@I!r36_1hb7 zm1`yon|cQP1;ZxU+A{gKSVX4)aKrr(TaVAdymRbDQQcK!iwJZM!?P3jn+*J4AT&rw z&)~OreGIcBnizEzhhhn}#x5+8X;QFdB-0ou)ad)>Uvv&I0_LkTxq+pgfp-nMDiO=m zG0*4OP)1@O`wMbP4~9(L9>k_WPh^cE-A`(fMCS zYx1_MT$C09%Os`$ed>?2BUoWazrloUflf+xKZjOW~aZ`g`NARf&-=V5iyf0qV z3a3N37i2L?ZaBL#^kJ0c| zF??myp^Bc>T@e;G;BSDE=fE5b8ALzIY@B+@J>81+^uLPo%F>S2u)%`z{)B%ge^u@t zVhfBN$xd98Uraz7+3madS%vJ*ry@uINP#R8PJG25V>bUZKz2|^Ut%TaMa+JX)?6$K z(;nW84Z0#D|L_AA40N?46bjei#v)3D^% zxOQIR>)Ae77b+fEEy$Ik>IvOjV~?)S^n_cMH*u(O_6?n=iaBGc74_~kvnJ<|rMr;J z@PvmB=@2j>Q5Zs2{v#$xb^CemO$Yg#sP2X$aKn+^BW8^+PH%v?r&ndm5_5znKlPn; zOS^J?`AN_uf-?imkFtDIc7Nf6vSs*~A5gY#*{26?G}O!rUvABj<6_#iQTLZH^8vIp zQdC_Fepb*&6zIVcB$Qb@U-H%!1WasQNaYUyxs+qFld zCOgNee>6|7$zOzrV95voV66W3VF_4TE}=2|u$$Q8>0kv06N${-(L&pYM`BFAf8imX zq5grN6+>R&>7gqF8#054-rUn4^Eo=kyXK7SKJ4ntIR#eOCg+Q*Z$KVhv-Jkg6x#0@ zqfV$9a}|Q0Kj)W2@=0jZ^7gke?QdwItPj$q6s>ddbm{W>*CbM9oR{lkz+wg;*kWaL zv!aNC{@4Iem`xyeQif+-c=1GY3-~6eJ@^q7HAK{CXrOE_&YCi9h zih23UsMn#-!|eepN0m9CV~ymZWi(EA+Ddc0htR+(rZRveeEGN6s9eYm1brBY90IWMMf65$Gq1BAk7X*pkAl zJUcF0`qk#^>*8U-`-7~d(araCGtuwXR_}Z?YzX)o0k$FN?bLqN97?+yPOU+Qf^H;v z=hrd?55wlv<+L_^U;9>iEYImA$6oQw`*$MHg$1RZh{L%wa8XK3(kD9)+Bw3Exoo1eVj(rob()+vQ z*_cC!iq522vgk8Lp%a_RBwcK+lr(TeN9!XJFp6HgwH#+GwPr&}*KRHCelxl*Un&xX z@8}87^F`WmxdXBJhLp6v+JMT0M$UG3M5vPXq&nY!tjH6*e$aD2Bzow(rmFSQ;6)vG zfO*8hNj`Hu>zx>2%=}`Ov`!c+IRi;o2f_2q*6ThY6!$jdjGiNMBOoDDB{1fi8une% zK^u??MkF%!T1noSkV+HRRoCTLSF{1f=@LC=J9!u6prUEht#8$2 z60`nFft5Wj9!#Geg`r`Zj<$l^6YxPS{!8r(Ap-mpXt zdO?YV32DQgMQs-5?b|b&yINWP6oW`BRGNp;=9*^luiSw5vOe80Ta(`$)IQP?2_b!$ zBSjqusnV58KdXt*2ScYXV|i#j&JzgBfwr-<}vBqPg#A=vhGS4oh}FPHB@SZ&tEWu zJ-IqzHV%d%^LzdSHy(wQLv)ow0>uj<_xV!*A=~cYH>J~DH10W>4vU%_M-$DvbjLt| z!U*MrWQmQaweUL$cV$5&DCLm{<~Y&Ji-P*9H7ZGOr4}G;v?7*3#(G zOzKRHy|m51pkl|S>J>>#I^8Kk9Sdh`yoUNvzVT@#AEG)N;2+u%mHb-oprjPQQ+Iw~ z`68z>#wM9oZ*48jh_Ix#srflK&;Tl@9{fB56ISI-5$QBrIE>oyE% z|7y56-=l0NZoDkn)ksw0O~nd##Mu(CE>$(;GK!)E5?9|0b~esZK}^13*&TEv0)_iO}HLGUF?1H92offoCB3iiE0` zKmr~8fSUQ`pm){i*j#Z4dBN-X8!utrjd`8a&UdIM0su_WCk~W#LIY!cWeMCkoTyu@ zKn>hC^0SA7L7_D4^i-vLfGg>5U?lGb*xbs%O2+MZ*yi2U5Nw0e-*H|)K(qFv&_pdd z_&NOm6clzN$&EFMkbykmLzDVfDzFrv?~x@a2V-Yu>p07svSy6CmLo}};$ z)a;1vTE9eJH}5iTie9s0uBou0O`uYIB1$p)?0Ibg$?qudCZM<>_AsUyV!Z| z*oYG0>J&3>AHXvqQgEeiHx<;`^0m$W-ZSdl=>^uC>-7spuFKEuiW_ff6`#o@LrHg7 zCZJD-J1a+!$N<|r)M(0&+l0sB3IwQi-NtgsNC|#L&UUxWsLW1Lk5T1I)0C-#$M}fH z%@2TanD|9r!oxkv&48|NjLuvkdQ}ArjrF``cY15URs|2dA_PPtJIZo=$9C43dBQw4 z&1~()^X>jQ$KEL`J2`7DlmIfbSX?IpG4(plb~Wr#y+6O_R#pBqJI3+ze3oE(BWqXW zM&v+Kb3fGUC-&21*Q|S4%d}6rsXRv zjYRvn^1rxyAAlJ26EFf2;(GBhcFJ+zKraH<{J0L^YmllR;d=8Wz^{?~Xc+9Od58O* z^j~b|1%Z4DR}CNl0NDRS`v0SZ{G0m!t%@|wZ^-uJqx4*>5gcyL%4S7ktWDG#w`k(| z&CbQD=lU}_+tRgbaP9`PX|sMfJO{>Ax8Ql`+a7t@M*9(t`{yY%U&v5x7p-qq>UU`H z{lur}{Mq4iOHIw7%P+>v>u{kGs`>mQ#$3>%axT8F!19TFp~C7L-7l}v4KFb5DdT;M zfe-0MnK`O;4d;3DquAbcZ0BIwD}S7?fEV&Leo3=U;y}fz!EHTmjKL*yem;cU!hLPT zAG}Dx)}p-*q^*tfA+D9#zDyTHM#)N2n3ko93w{Z^w4BAMngRyaDC?rVuIz_|Zwl&+ z$)>K3415t%(pB=RzC~f=ggYfNU_N&bD_%gqdoO4uipcuYYhIrR&hOqcwY7D!v2`+W z{7X6c+kG-o0&qYCFd{XA?XD5DQ4IY*Y~b{70bo_};ezE2xx1-#-a8-OJAH0!c-NV~ z*xO}Nqoe9&O9TWCdvj^)>l|QR&WGkPsIU+rIwN@2s0rVFV>(u*9LKMjWxQk1>XCex z@xL}c$5{ISN7wfGy`5rOJ?|O_;hQIM**hsAMD>Y9^+wxuUGk%}9l)^1?u&xD=|1DK=7MtDj+(UA6?L_Po?y&;{Y+{zY| z!;6hx4|BkVI$tEqwh5bJRx-y|62Xe!#xsu`IkS$2D$tf>Jl>453ZFK(MnJrM)5k3+ zv`e*x5Ez|t3(7!Ebqh@EP#Oi#NiB@0VQ2*goGz$0^@0H4Ao``tJISha7TNAIs(~+g}fug^tqXtLTY^ z0bxJwy}mpGfxl%pCi%-i>K7rmGS-m@R5~%Lkv5xzsmPv<4G2LR7A15t))9Sv-KR#1 zD}g|j^_mo}gJGD21!%HU2U6E312{p2x}id8jy`n!b~Tr0_+{xkehc3r44-2N%Vcpx z!(G}<-B^UgW1C3SPlPP00ur6$H~)yOBKq1adQ&cgN|(On^B|07;I*y zXUn9m;+T54OszqdY_x3S9%Gb!Q5cmIf@I?L8Bph26!kQT$|@^7tQG&(=8I8-KuYJ! z&CARMkKmccNZV2DJNmunG{elK!v)>5Uh^rN$H&yeW%j1W-b#pWY_m&e%VWMT{(v_Z zy4wLDuKxqLL!OX{XHcx)G+{Sh?%O8g&o7K`L{206+}K}%VXXO&k~#zTJ>JY4$_OC#wG_|4HxZdcvCX)^r`4+cI2W0#ZvP?U+M4)J4^fMZ-DN?GNwGd=gHvt zd(Ys>$(c~qsDA}M%$9_OI?RW^%9w~3bDsG)yfSs3i+vF~oJfIX8|VNuiztm_KgNpOx@lV8>XK6caeRZx6tWVE81zPy@9w{+S6W=c!LGWx#=`5UeU%><5 zb!!M~ml-_Kqz^6dAPFkgD|7Eg7p|j1XT9pn+TdD|>^9Cr{qyY>V5e?3JG6OtLVUo> zepMK}EW%1Tc~2Rw&04C}$_VZbln7}0*5MwWTVyQGZ3rX0feG;N+Yf?+BacAyqxHdr zah?2)8&n^%Su|rD4};j-bg*2_P0qnwt8w>jF@4}lH~=)DsT;w8h;O*5Ykp3e{iW<9 zwL6)R(pyAF=m>+Hqi3 z*Pwd4H-sn!?gUUzk_Auk5`kSo?(9-Phr;D?KJ{!06J5`KpFj_nFd`oy#M?*f>oY-k zrO^h{aGqftF%BNbXTy!<&;c>i)QzY0Z=l|?+mGvY=P}Kbka7Z2aQxCxn?fcT6EQ=W zJb+?4(=eb!po1~!<6ukLz4i#E0EKT6Dma|QE<_SEuq!3}O(8*H;5xQV`bRz9`JQGQ zN|YrH26*`u(e5enSg@a|2rdJIftMB$H#AkT%FYPDUieM#h5Iw~%f$pN+5X}%Epx%l=f{PhR&u|b&0GAh*BE443v{IT-F zJ7^$;cbrZ!3A_idU{8#`*sKRmA6%D0LE+9#GPS=wu z%@o|Kg|#WzL^s}yW{l5*%A*$p|IQQG884l}GoXy0jx?y5z5H8Z&!3&=eKXrCbZ zh9C96kD4LOu0hWZc#6d0IluUIX5#Nkf?%}p$JuX;+(tGOw<#SsEJ{<>na%=PlJbSI zWU)(*Fl>w9T8w2UQZnkV0s$A-Bm!=*Ur|5YR>qf@(YSfsOY&^s=zUG{Dr?%7I!}78 z2QIPQx5-v>xakCCo6;-G;Mx)IiYK~5#V-41u4GlWXc&7KKS}>^*1Vqd0ZmSqQ~zR$s&KO}M)XpS2xcc}! z?vu=JjLq?3^J6AAk!3CYt4rUwT=D_*CTe3De7-DRXIor^{z(M?&^1vJ#!kZoN}H z@y5TSVX)P(VN80blPE)6p!k!#c@!bYVKpAVpS>nXC&bf1v$X9_oEK9b{rX}EjBr|7 zD79WDos`e-d_hb4!W_FxfaNwCE#6(eU9F(>0LC_LoY`?53#R;dCa_$A=BmUHb~|~@ zv@QgLgDlxE=_0GWl-}(TlxpliI^}AiXks`{LP;ww7h6i0s-XFPM1HQIlos!a`LhAa z(%Z>hMWX5aoRaffyxygaT34Z5o=bj-!u*svsf?}7?m)l`J~GV@RQtT6Q|S^pP8wpR z1ia_hK*WLx>&>X!5NBD%bKF(oj4CvfhiUfr{cu&JtGHMhC{r=l$){4(Fc1GI-8XH+ zIIZORNJ)HC*}{*yDMg=x+MQ(c@9>zyHnJ?73gppHhhLuQyiCzn@*}uu-0a{`A zvGysR^&AijN5<@dEh>{?Q zu6*`@_6NgRVf#J^$cRXh-vV;PB8gLQUBvfn?0!|`U;q|pJMBjbh8{aq5W=Ft>C~ZJ zDypg(Ek$>b7{;atty&w^xLdwH8~sf_Qdpi0y(xaE#(S7LACayCR2%EmaryQuSnc5C zdhjVaSp~3HBl^Ul>5T+w??|!6m6AaAXk#)voL}?+_`=Y#J6{J!?azaJPmBE8IP8a)9&7=)K-b`8=j}<7Sy3)| zkpzG(Cw;d1D2BnK1`$aSoxZrcy;BEdOH#^BJhENBegAzX*$IGbf%?gerGWp%nSNt+ zS@FF#f%GsTdZ7EVLawQ#Ah(Klpv^q|D1za_J0q;do-aj>RyqqZrD$TwZ@%BHN>;sF z2{K^fLG>cfixJYUF*Q$Po7{Z4_UH_kl?2qaqU4(3 zrYU48a7{q0fCE^C!w}(I6h6LGXfeF;Gf+%Ub+V zG3O11^>pRi8ZiBHceMklrV_^+$csNv60nlHTWM5l<)pMwzD^j^ls^u81TMfM#7Bs| z;?jkHqkotC&WAR5CpTs|n$tTk7-)7n{Df3PO0En;uDH_NL~bg>4$2+eF_C6P$-y?# zruN>t?p&yq;^k>1R57gv$)fkW7x8R>kyk$F;r5^G^M8v9jBKs{sww!J8fVS)M)cz& zfNiTmZYs_3B#NZpE8ask!{ZMz3l4q5Kz_JhnpHo_BiSQnyzynoU2eY5(?C_I>clNqP+5@9ta0`lUvZDhvY{2}wq8zyS`}sbiHG5YA1K4I_cG z|FrtSk6!Zc=?C}%Ty&^li}cG6lgrTQ$L|3F19|w3UkJEPQV$P$L1{6Y4GC*d%fZYb zFkaLTVM{~nu}K(wC4bN-cQ@LqE5=^6v5yzzS53#| z=kX5`MhMF=vDK=$jy(%*w2jSZq)75Ooj6T<sOW$wilLYDA#ux15v5?9c_!{O9pkvDH7mbar&Iwf@VSS(Cj`ee?(*(|V9?E#bJrl5@HP z4WTDpg&C~+^#mO>&kw~AK7PXnA;XPtRNRALY22bj@J-1;`GcdwD*qxQr8n zR6b-P5|aup>&&M_PaheSAr zKO9MZ;_lDzAMd)yR~o{h&d7tX&3qfXlQ;O9NbHpQQYPGRkq|02lKYWFGTrAGSuMX9 z{8ctbsT!WAoCor&AaXg3NO^2}X%t-NGjtx`H;jvC^J^Mi!8ZP@Oe;;~pwiIlDZI70|z^M%jSgDjl z_skWw;E7K^O=7c^|U-GBK?B?jQX;Oh_zL zK14}8_+@O}71L#3;(L2^E8qLx0r!$#!zwZt@-ZqlV@LI#63k_3UegeuJ|bzMd%Nnt z^uu1L2g!qL9uDDPN^zfW7nW|P7kS^J?)1SBl=i+P@puYq< zJjaJ%nM&n}U;4+L6KY%K|0Llwxbd41vqG#L45I;V#;zOp(}`K8)UQBY!&6tP z5So#?fWP^V(p6XDkmYX8BB%4RMEpZ(k1#gEA|Q>5J9 zeR~!&EBr6yb`~lw9HAse63)}($^_?e7G7s2L#)j| z*rFBeb{DkZX&VN;d?vSv0_SpL`^?qhV#Xg{^_0%PY@}qLPWky5s-nCOie(M#Lz)SR zEEgvrGJh2zvId&$2F$;d$EmWfIc`s=2K7dNk(qw%vX2|M4rs_DJfjRcB#r3K|s3%q6*MB=8EOtN2!9Ni!l4_3=k z0P$rcF3W>YR^?S3XrASL$c!eB*5|~Mx1HIO^Oq_)pX@dJTow*w7yG$#!Y&aW-(m@~yvx1m94ED+{D&oD=YpXhq`0%`2R&=Jl@9a5^-b>t~lE zm@(Z-Fh5LP<@)muB_cH|D5!^7Dw-v~0n(T|#m`f!Qlyw_q{oY`}RyE7M&q}LBs zZfKUA@69Bpm}f39!_L_(O1d*oB1Lzk7q43=pUL7zXXIZ)!VP00wJ27#Q-%Y5^CKYP z@<>iUO;2hb%g^8WCbCQeWG^mMM~VdOCa$4Yt>i)`zl{)P5fn0=&?-ty4sQK}2&e=s zOkcbWo7H+e-av!(e9(3b8i^D{i8+lUwkA7L1bp3y9m#n&d3{>E%KPT|ZgftKOwO0j z{r+t4xJDl>)+>)_+5acG%+*DS?YsLm$>U24-WJb?3v678zpd}n$vK{{O=F%s@%zR8 zni}1f*TMy#iM|e0Y!YB%Ss|!?Eh_SK+UCQ2ejYx2cbU1sOsEOG@?dyHs|(G=4|8joA|`|)Q_ zgN68D+ee2P74er#1nKZpjM#mW!J+%_aPI(!>?dKI^+?yf%%aRlrLii)$~lZBLl7)l zENl5G*kMENvX?WX66M!K!g`F@`61T7mx0cP9Zr=DThMqwmlGiKg@%pO^4R1! z(+0L7ae$i(FNL?WO&BjyzyOadUO1aowwskq83WCPz+MkY8uU_6vRm$Ti~~RVyqvwr zU++Jr)j(!YKu=}C5kFoD^&GwGYXEL-<@1QkcRSwWgLSO#5Y;7kSz%v6`s9^so44dAB+2~Dz|-{_xVSUAt+GTmZPwC(9=R{283TL#n8|PcNxUvr zkFDoaiiUF{651|;bFy0LG?Q|WPxm|<*?rq^A+><(Q`VqQAN`6ku&<82bs5e7!%cq z6Mn)p{{5r0+XS%1OTMKMnWEh2=D=gquX~Y{{2JPf(&v-e7&#0_eqL#;a3vg0op}K0LD17`BsrfSXYYljMw8%g_{p2xR zGw|%P)~6>GcW4qmSTbmWa4)x2*{`b=7#j|>+NJT%1=#0msSHe&9zwqJZ*F+#o00a% z%1T*6x@f613Q7A&P5BpAPh^>io9STEGaDO=n8;Qi~e%G*~ZQ zny+sZCBJ=vG~0Et!Fq1&1WCHJ6*#dW##Q&IW2Oap6H2>ZHHRP*zS=n^_aH{Mn$Yvk zNXcIrSiv17N~PCk!_AN_Sg+4g?XBd@5^Pgug;pt1pk&4_F?Pltw_-adGi#ymgQqql zl}7_hm6qEokr_(aEQ38*l1SmfM6qxvP?GK$O=hJ5$YDXkHgw zvFQl@S~O4IXw_oPW?bgj5lsfhE{Uo&;nK0@d={`4e>!H`Pr;mCq}p5MlKxqWow!!4 zt?{fj6|1gVm@d4RndFlkOj@{&OJc-3m@A!)0sPz3-q zMu~%|bQtzK1+gTmJXtdM(Lkq`11Fo~DX@ftw829lzv@_!yMwmsRK5TB+QjN^;xq)H zU89J-n2<=-iAgZe8g>$#KYQn`r2)Hntt*lQhRW$FCK4bad;vjF=ZSlX4qmdNApuM8 znJ&YrD?ozwQUJ;Ve$@J6NWwQ?7Di`^C4GG6}yI7qmGf|uMtX+&>VHCz_T zBI(+aL>h?+2QApY;WQ!~Z`;B!61^vxMRwOAnvi{$G}UlivO= zsQA;=pH&Y3n9BJKmcLE?R`c*D{?E1JfAHaG|Hc2alKdz5Pr2|P@EpN^!N2{3KkQ zzWY~_{t5q+z5W9aAph6(|I20nME}XO{z0Qq{`ca4@~%Hk{5iz@V?vkVf4lEr1J0lL jKkrQc;LVu+i~r+3B`*aE_SdfvKA$k3)mJRce|`Et=qe$> literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.md b/paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c7926ee --- /dev/null +++ b/paper/變更摘要_給Jimmy_20260623.md @@ -0,0 +1,38 @@ +# Paper A v13 修訂摘要(給 Jimmy)— 2026-06-23 + +**現行版本**:rev9.1(`Paper_full_v13_filled_rev9_20260623.docx` / PDF 同名)。源檔 `paper/v13_build/paper_v13_filled.md`,已 commit+push 至 `paper-a-v4-big4`。 + +**一句話**:用三份 AI 審稿(Gemini 3.1 + ChatGPT 5.5 + Opus 4.8 融合,共 29 點;另加兩輪 ChatGPT 5.5 敵意審稿)逐點修訂。所有新數字皆由資料庫實算、可重現,**未杜撰任何數據**。 + +--- + +## 一、核心宣稱「誠實化」(最重要,請確認你能接受降溫幅度) + +- **撤回「139×」式比較**。原本「Firm A 觸發率 = 巧合率的 139 倍」是把「同一人重複」除以「不同人互撞」,方向高估。改為只報原始比率(A 82% vs B/C/D 24–35%),不再乘除。 +- **specificity → specificity proxy**:我們沒有 labeled negatives,明說 ICCR 是「不同會計師間的巧合率」,**不是**真正的偽陽率、連上下界都不是。 +- **新增 §III-F「What HC Means and Does Not Mean」**:白紙黑字寫「**HC 不是 reuse 標籤**」——HC 只代表「同一會計師極端重複、且在不相關會計師間罕見」。reuse 是其中一種詮釋,Firm A 由 byte-identical + 訪談另外支撐;**B/C/D 完全不作 reuse 宣稱**。 +- **Firm A 改稱 known-positive / quasi-positive benchmark**,不再包裝成嚴格 blinded test(因為訪談早已知道它是 stamping firm)。 +- **訪談降為 contextual / corroborative**,明說「非 validation、不可獨立重製」。 + +## 二、新增的實證強化(讓宣稱更站得住) + +- **Table VI(any-pair vs same-pair)**:審稿質疑「cosine 與 dHash 來自不同配對、HC 是拼湊的」。實算反駁——改用嚴格 same-pair(同一配對需同時滿足兩條件),Firm A 仍 **57.3%**、B/C/D 跌到 5–9%,**A/其他的比值反而從 2.4–3.4× 升到 6.4–10.8×**。 +- **F5 穩健性四連檢**(§IV-C):pool-size 分層、會計師層 bootstrap(差距 53.7pp [49.5, 57.5])、firm+year 固定效果、逐年剔除(53.1–54.9pp)——firm 差異穿透所有控制。 +- **Table V — 影像管線審計(880 份 PDF)**:純掃描比例 2013 **82%** → 2021 **崩到 1%**,metadata 直接點名掃描機型(Fuji Xerox D125 等)。同時:(a) 坐實「事務所=影像管線」混淆是真的;(b) 但 Firm A 在純掃描年代就已高 HC,反證其訊號**不是**數位化 artifact。 +- **byte-identical 分期**:262 筆中 30 筆在掃描年代(18 在 Firm A,掃描雜訊無法偽造 → 重用鐵證)、232 筆在數位年代(誠實標註此暴增含「可偵測性」成分)。 +- 其餘:Figure 3 換真實密度圖、新增 Figure 6 閾值敏感度面、G5 補「全庫期望巧合 HC ≈ 888 件」。 + +## 三、需要你知道/拍板的三個判斷 + +1. **Framing 採「rebalance 不 relabel」**:審稿建議把全文改寫成「無標籤校準方法(審計只是 case study)」。我**沒有照做最強版**——把方法升為主貢獻、但**保留審計發現當 headline**,且**不宣稱 "general framework"**(避免「一個案例憑什麼叫 general」的新攻擊)。請確認你同意這個定位。 +2. **不做 within-CPA「真親簽」對照組**:理想上該比「真人親簽的 HC 誤觸率」,但我們沒有標記的親簽資料、公開資料集又是不同族群——硬借會引入新假設。已在 §III-E 主動說明「考慮過、刻意不做」。 +3. **PDF 管線發現是雙刃**:它讓「事務所混淆」更嚴重(我們誠實寫出),但同時用掃描年代證據鞏固核心。兩面都寫了,沒挑對我們有利的講。 + +## 四、剩餘待辦(你/投稿前) + +- 作者、機構、DOI、biography placeholder(double-blind,投稿前補) +- IEEE 模板最終排版;related work 可再收斂;表格 II-b/IV 是否整併 +- 人工 review protocol 首次執行(未做,已列 future work) + +--- +*完整逐點對照見 `paper/fusion_review_todo.md`(29/29 已處理)。所有分析腳本在 `paper/v13_build/scripts/`,可一鍵重現。*