# VI. Conclusion and Future Work

## Conclusion

We have presented an end-to-end AI pipeline for detecting non-hand-signed auditor signatures in financial audit reports at scale.
Applied to 90,282 audit reports from Taiwanese publicly listed companies spanning 2013--2023, our system extracted and analyzed 182,328 CPA signatures using a combination of VLM-based page identification, YOLO-based signature detection, deep feature extraction, and dual-descriptor similarity verification, with threshold selection placed on a statistically principled footing through two methodologically distinct threshold estimators and a density-smoothness diagnostic applied at two analysis levels.

Our contributions are fourfold.

First, we argued that non-hand-signing detection is a distinct problem from signature forgery detection, requiring analytical tools focused on the upper tail of intra-signer similarity rather than inter-signer discriminability.

Second, we showed that combining cosine similarity of deep embeddings with difference hashing is essential for meaningful classification---among 71,656 documents with high feature-level similarity, the dual-descriptor framework revealed that only 41% exhibit converging structural evidence of non-hand-signing while 7% show no structural corroboration despite near-identical feature-level appearance, demonstrating that a single-descriptor approach conflates style consistency with image reproduction.

Third, we introduced a convergent threshold framework combining two methodologically distinct estimators---KDE antimode (with a Hartigan unimodality test) and an EM-fitted Beta mixture (with a logit-Gaussian robustness check)---together with a Burgstahler-Dichev / McCrary density-smoothness diagnostic.
Applied at both the signature and accountant levels, this framework surfaced an informative structural asymmetry: at the per-signature level the distribution is a continuous quality spectrum for which no two-mechanism mixture provides a good fit, whereas at the per-accountant level BIC cleanly selects a three-component mixture and the KDE antimode together with the Beta-mixture and logit-Gaussian estimators agree within $\sim 0.006$ at cosine $\approx 0.975$.
The Burgstahler-Dichev / McCrary test, by contrast, finds no significant transition at the accountant level; at $N = 686$ accountants the test has limited power and cannot affirmatively establish smoothness, but its non-transition is consistent with the smoothly-mixed cluster boundaries implied by the accountant-level GMM.
The substantive reading is therefore narrower than "discrete behavior": *pixel-level output quality* is continuous and heavy-tailed, and *accountant-level aggregate behavior* is clustered into three recognizable groups whose inter-cluster boundaries are gradual rather than sharp.

Fourth, we introduced a *replication-dominated* calibration methodology---explicitly distinguishing replication-dominated from replication-pure calibration anchors and validating classification against a byte-level pixel-identity anchor (310 byte-identical signatures) paired with a $\sim$50,000-pair inter-CPA negative anchor.
To document the within-firm sampling variance of using the calibration firm as its own validation reference, we split the firm's CPAs 70/30 at the CPA level and report capture rates on both folds with Wilson 95% confidence intervals; extreme rules agree across folds while rules in the operational 85-95% capture band differ by 1-5 percentage points, reflecting within-firm heterogeneity in replication intensity rather than generalization failure.
This framing is internally consistent with all available evidence: the visual-inspection observation of pixel-identical signatures across unrelated audit engagements for the majority of calibration-firm partners; the 92.5% / 7.5% split in signature-level cosine thresholds; and, among the 171 calibration-firm CPAs with enough signatures to enter the accountant-level GMM (of 180 in total), the 139 / 32 split between the high-replication and middle-band clusters.

An ablation study comparing ResNet-50, VGG-16 and EfficientNet-B0 confirmed that ResNet-50 offers the best balance of discriminative power, classification stability, and computational efficiency for this task.

## Future Work

Several directions merit further investigation.
Domain-adapted feature extractors, trained or fine-tuned on signature-specific datasets, may improve discriminative performance beyond the transferred ImageNet features used in this study.
Extending the accountant-level analysis to auditor-year units---using the same convergent threshold framework at finer temporal resolution---could reveal within-accountant transitions between hand-signing and non-hand-signing over the decade.
The pipeline's applicability to other jurisdictions and document types (e.g., corporate filings in other countries, legal documents, medical records) warrants exploration.
The replication-dominated calibration strategy and the pixel-identity anchor technique are both directly generalizable to settings in which (i) a reference subpopulation has a known dominant mechanism and (ii) the target mechanism leaves a byte-level signature in the artifact itself.
Finally, integration with regulatory monitoring systems and a larger negative-anchor study---for example drawing from inter-CPA pairs under explicit accountant-level blocking---would strengthen the practical deployment potential of this approach.
